Positive Action Group - Possan Jantys Jarrooagh

Open, accountable government, rigorous control of public finances, and a fairer society for all.

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home The News Latest News Freedom of Information (FoI) - Part 2 - Costs exaggerated?

Freedom of Information (FoI) - Part 2 - Costs exaggerated?

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 8

The Chief Minister stated "...such a piece of legislation (FOI) might come at a high cost" in his Keys answer (01.11.11).


Later he went on to say  "we are basing that at the moment on the experience in Jersey, where the cost ran into many millions to actually get it established and I think there is an annual  running cost of somewhere in the region of ¬£1 million a year."


In a subsequent interview for Manx Radio  he again referred to Jersey "...but we must understand the fact that in jersey for example it cost them over ¬£4 million pounds to bring in the original structure and I think the annual running cost is over a ¬£1 million...."


Mr Bell you are not right.

The States of Jersey, only  in May, adopted  a new Freedom of Information (Jersey) Law 201-. It has yet to be implemented, a process which could take about 4 years.

In the months prior, Jersey's Council of Minsters was making the same pronouncements as Mr Bell is now making here.


They claimed a £5.6 million was needed to implement FOI with £1.3 million a year running costs and that cuts would have to be made in the business and strategic plans.


In April the final version of a specially commissioned independent consultants  Report "States of Jersey Freedom of Information Implementation Plan" was published.


Within it costs are given, and these in no way correspond to the inflated figures being bandied about by Mr Bell.


The costings are specific to the circumstances and particular requirements of Jersey. They are not all 'up front' costs, but occur incrementally over the 4 year implementation period.

And remember the figures are estimated not actual.


PAG decided to uncover firm evidence of the cost of FOI.


We found out that an investigation by BBC Radio Cornwall had calculated that each FOI request cost the Unitary Authority £150 to process. Incidentally, over a 2 year period less than 10% of the 2264 requests were from the Media.


Based on Cornwall's figures we extrapolate, here in IOM, the annual running cost would be £26250 to process 175 requests (This is based on requests per head of population).


Another calculation we did, based on UK published figures for the first quarter of 2011, gives a much lower number of FOI requests here at 68.


Are there any indicative figures nearer to home?


Yes, in a written answer to July Tynwald it was estimated that a total of 697 questions had been asked by politicians in Keys, LegCo and Tynwald (October 2010 to July 2011) at a calculated cost of ¬£89.30 per question. Total ¬£62242.10


So there's our calculation of running costs for FOI  Chief Minister. - now let's have yours.


We also challenge you to publish the paper you and your Ministers considered at your meeting on November 2nd. After all this legislation is about openness and transparency.



+2 #1 Consultation Code ignored!wilfred tomlinson 2011-11-22 09:58
The government's own Code of Practice on Consultation has the following criteria which must be followed - look at number 6.

CoMin didn't abide by their own Code in relation to FOI

The Six Consultation Criteria

1. Consult widely throughout the process, allowing a minimum of 6 weeks for a minimum of one written consultation at least once during the development of the legislation or policy.

2. Be clear about what your proposals are, who may be affected, what questions are being asked and the timescale for responses.

3. Ensure your consultation is clear, concise and widely accessible.

4. Give feedback regarding the responses received and how the consultation process influenced the policy.

5. Monitor your Department’s effectiveness at consultation.

6. Ensure your consultation follows best practice, including carrying out an Impact Assessment if appropriate.

These criteria must be followed in consultation documents.

Add comment

Please note that unregistered visitors are required to add their email and 'captcha code' in order to prevent spam and advertising. Your email address will NEVER be published. Registered members do not need to enter this - why not register today?

Security code



Our occasional newsletter provides details of forthcoming events and features new website articles.

Main Menu